Car valuation
How much is my car worth?
There isn't one answer, and anyone who gives you a single number without seeing the car is guessing. Your car has at least three different values depending on who is buying it and why — and knowing which one you're being quoted is the difference between a fair deal and a bad one.
Your car has three values, not one
Most arguments about what a car is “worth” happen because two people are talking about two different numbers. There are three that matter, and they are always different:
| Retail value | Private sale value | Trade / wholesale value | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who pays it | A buyer at a dealership | Another private buyer | A dealer buying from you |
| Includes | Reconditioning, warranty, margin | No warranty, no recourse | Cash today, no selling effort |
| Your effort | Not available to you | Weeks of ads, calls, test drives | One form, one inspection |
| Your risk | Not available to you | Payment fraud, strangers, haggling | Paid by a licensed business |
| Varies between buyers | Very little | Somewhat | A lot — this is the one to compare |
1. Retail value
What the car sits on a dealer’s yard advertised at. This is the number you see when you search your model online, and it is the highest of the three. It includes the dealer’s reconditioning spend, statutory warranty exposure, holding costs, advertising, floor space and margin. You will not be paid retail value by anyone, because you are not offering the things that justify it.
2. Private sale value
What another private buyer will pay you directly. Typically below retail, because the buyer gets no warranty, no recourse and no finance option from you. It is usually the highest number you can personally realise — and it costs you weeks of messages, strangers at your house, test drives and payment risk to get there.
3. Trade or wholesale value
What a dealer will hand you cash for today. It is retail value minus reconditioning, minus warranty risk, minus holding cost, minus margin. This is the number a trade-in offer, a cash-for-cars buyer and a dealer offer are all quoting — and it is the number that varies most between buyers, because every one of those subtractions is different at every dealership.
That last point is the one worth remembering. Retail value is roughly the same across the market. Wholesale value is not. The reasons dealers land on different numbers are structural, not random.
What actually moves the number
In rough order of how much they matter to a dealer pricing your car:
- Model and variant. Not just “a Ranger” — a Ranger XLT dual-cab auto 4x4 is a different car commercially to a single-cab XL 4x2. Variant, drivetrain and transmission can move a price by thousands.
- Current demand for that exact car. What a dealer will pay depends on whether they can retail it quickly. Demand shifts month to month and differs by city.
- Kilometres. Important, but less decisive than owners assume — a well-serviced Prado at 190,000 km can be worth more than a neglected European SUV at 90,000 km.
- Service history. A complete logbook removes risk from the dealer’s calculation, and risk is priced in dollars. A car with no history at all gets priced for the worst case.
- Condition, inside and out. Panel damage, kerbed wheels, tyre tread, a torn seat, cigarette smell. Each one is a line item in a reconditioning estimate.
- Tyres and brakes. Four tyres near the wear indicators is a real, quantifiable cost the dealer will carry before the car can be sold.
- Number of keys. A missing second key is a genuine replacement and programming cost. Find it before you sell.
- Colour and spec. White, silver and grey move fastest. A sunroof, tow bar or factory nav can help; heavy aftermarket modification usually hurts.
- Written-off or repaired history. Checked as a matter of routine, and it changes both the price and the pool of dealers willing to buy.
- Finance owing. Doesn’t reduce what the car is worth, but it has to be settled out of the sale. Selling a car with finance owing walks through how that works.
How to research your own car honestly
You can get yourself a realistic bracket in about twenty minutes. The trick is knowing what you’re looking at.
- Find your exact variant. Check your compliance plate and your original paperwork. Guessing the trim level is the most common way owners end up with an unrealistic expectation.
- Search listings for the same year, variant and similar kilometres. Note the range, not the top of it.
- Remember those are asking prices, not sold prices. A car advertised at $32,000 might have been on the yard for eleven weeks. What it eventually sells for is a different number, and what a dealer paid for it is different again.
- Subtract for the dealer’s costs. Reconditioning, warranty, holding and margin all sit between the advertised price and what anyone will pay you.
- Adjust honestly for your car. Compare your tyres, your service history and your panels to the listings you found — not to how you feel about the car.
Why instant online valuations are only a starting point
Automated valuation tools price the average example of your model. They can’t see the stone chip across your bonnet, the full logbook in your glovebox, or the fact that a dealer twenty minutes away sold three of yours last month and wants another.
They’re useful for a sanity check. They are not an offer, and the gap between an instant estimate and what someone will actually pay is exactly where sellers get disappointed.
DealerOffer deliberately doesn’t show you an instant number. We ask you to describe the car properly once, then licensed dealers price it and commit to what they’ll pay. A real offer from a real buyer beats an algorithm’s guess, and it is the number you can actually act on.
Getting the highest number you can
Three things move your price more than anything else you can control:
- Present it properly. Wash it, clear it out, and photograph it well. Dealers price what they can see.
- Produce the paperwork. Logbook, receipts, both keys, owner’s manual. Every gap is priced as risk.
- Get more than one buyer looking. One offer tells you what one dealer thinks on one day. Several tell you where the market actually is.
Frequently asked questions
Is a free online car valuation accurate?
It's a reasonable starting bracket and a poor final answer. Automated tools price a typical example of your model and year using historical sale data. They can't assess your car's condition, service history, tyres, damage or spec, and they don't know which dealers are currently short of your model.
Treat an instant valuation as a sanity check on your expectations, then get real offers before you decide anything.
Why is a dealer's offer lower than the price I see the same car advertised for?
Because the advertised price is retail and the offer is wholesale. Between those two numbers sits reconditioning, safety and mechanical work, statutory warranty exposure, detailing, advertising, weeks of floor space, and the dealer's margin.
That gap is normal and it exists at every dealership. What varies — often by thousands — is how big it is, which is why comparing several offers matters more than arguing about any one of them.
Does a car valuation cost anything?
Getting offers through DealerOffer is free and there is no obligation to accept any of them. If you want an independent mechanical inspection or a formal written valuation for insurance or legal purposes, that's a separate paid service through a qualified inspector or valuer.
How long is a valuation or offer valid for?
Used car values move, so offers are time-limited rather than open-ended. Your offers page shows how long each one stands.
An offer also assumes the car matches what you described. If the inspection turns up something significant that wasn't disclosed, the dealer can review it — which is exactly why describing it accurately up front protects your price.
Do modifications increase what my car is worth?
Usually not, and often the opposite. Aftermarket wheels, exhausts, suspension and tunes narrow the pool of buyers and can raise questions about how the car has been driven. Dealers frequently price a modified car as though it will need returning to standard.
Practical accessories are the exception — a tow bar, a canopy on a ute, or a genuine roof rack can help, because they suit the buyer who wants that car anyway. If you still have the original parts, say so.
Related reading
Make dealers compete for your car.
Up to 5 dealer offers. One form. No obligation.
Get My Dealer Offers